Good and Bad Powers of Buttons

By Margaret Johnson

Your Button Text Might Be Costing You Clicks

How’s that “Submit” button working for you? Or the ever-popular “Learn More” button? How about “Click Here”? Or “Download Now”?

Yes, it’s time to think about the buttons.

How Button Text Psychology Affects Click-Through Rates

The text you put on a button can make the difference between a click and a skip. It’s one more opportunity to be engaging and enticing – to tempt your visitors into clicking. Yet so often, we see the same ol’ boring button text.

What if you could simply use different words on your buttons to get different results? What if you could leverage what happens in people’s heads to stop them from skipping the clicking of your button? Think about it for a second.

Button Text That Kills Conversions

SUBMIT – I’m thinking of that South Park character, Cartman, who says “Respect my authoritay!” (I know it’s misspelled, but that’s how he says it.) Any way you slice it, the word “submit” can imply that the pushing of that button acknowledges subservience. For grins, I looked it up on dictionary.com and all the definitions it showed were essentially about others having more power than you do. (If you’re curious, you can look it up here.) Bottom line – who wants to fill in their information and click a button that says “Submit”?

Unfortunately, “submit” is the default button text for lots of different opt-in form builders – but you should have the power to change the button text regardless of what form builder you are using. However, effective form optimization strategiesgo beyond just button text to consider the entire user experience.

Why “Learn More” Falls Flat

LEARN MORE – This just promises that scholarly pursuits await you, doesn’t it? How fun does that sound? Yes, there are times when this button text is appropriate, but by and large, it’s an indication that it will take you to a page with lots of information on it. Fun, right? Nope.

The Problem With “Click Here”

CLICK HERE – A very commanding button, wouldn’t you say? If it builds even a smidgen of resistance in your mind, it will do the same for your site visitors or email readers. “You don’t get to tell me what to do!” could be the unfortunate mental reaction to such a command. This is frequently used with the Learn More text – Click Here to Learn More – so a double ugh for this one.

Why “Download Now” and “Register Now” Need an Upgrade

DOWNLOAD NOW – Do I have to? Seriously, this one isn’t so bad, but it’s also not terribly exciting or inspiring. We can do better.

REGISTER NOW – Yes, a registration form awaits you. Sounds exciting, doesn’t it? For those who are committed to take the action, it works just fine. But anyone waffling on their decision to click will likely respond better to a more engaging button.

High-Converting Button Text Examples That Drive Action

Let’s look at some button text that will be more engaging and inspire more actions, shall we?

The key is understanding the psychology behind crafting effective calls-to-action that truly convert.

First off, let’s stop using “Submit” as a button on the bottom of opt-in / lead capture forms. What you use instead depends on the purpose of the form itself.

Power-Focused Language for Lead Capture Forms

If a lead is filling in a form to get a lead magnet from you, how about using “Yes, I want this!” as your button text? Or “Get my copy now” could work as well. Or try “Yes, send it to me!” if you like that best. Did you notice that the language is putting the power in the hand of the clicker, versus “submit” which transfers power to the giver? That’s a powerful technique to use on a button.

Webinar Registration Buttons That Work

If the form is to register people into a webinar, consider button text along these lines: Save My Spot! Reserve My Seat! Claim My Spot! Doesn’t your brain react differently to those options than it does to “Register Now”?

Optimizing Contact Form and Meeting Request Buttons

If you’ve got a form on your website or landing page that’s for setting up a meeting, appointment, or requesting a contact, instead of “Submit” default, what about “Let’s Get Started” or perhaps “Contact Me Please“? These button improvements work even better when they’re part of comprehensive landing pages that evoke action throughout the entire user experience.

Compelling Alternatives to “Learn More” Buttons

For your website pages where you want people to click a button to go to another page for more information, what about ditching “Learn More” and replacing it with “See the Details,” “Check It Out,” or perhaps “Tell Me More”? If you’re linking people to a story you’ve told in a blog post, what about “Get Inspired by the Story” on your button?

The Psychology Behind Effort vs. Outcome Language

You may have picked up that the button text I labeled as “boring” above is all about the effort. Register, Download, Learn, Click – all are commands that say “you will do more work when you click this button.” See what I mean? The people contemplating the click will be asking themselves if the effort is worth the reward before they ever hit the button. After all, in most cases, they’re giving up their email address to get whatever you’re offering – and they’re likely savvy enough to know that action will add them to your email list and they’ll be on your radar.

If you focus instead on the outcome – Get My Copy, Save My Seat, etc., they’ll be less focused on the effort and more interested in what they’ll get. (Of course, to nail the right outcome language, you first need to know what truly matters to your audience.)

It’s subtle, yes. But it works.

Implementing Better Button Text: Key Takeaways

Calls to action, or CTAs, do a lot of heavy lifting when it comes to engaging your site visitors and your leads – and we don’t want to create any friction before a click is made. Thinking about and adapting your CTA button text, in forms and on your site pages, to more engaging and empowering text, will reduce friction and positively impact your results. For a deeper dive into optimizing all aspects of your CTAs, check out our comprehensive CTA evaluation guide.

P.S. I’m sure that there are places on our website where we’ve used boring button text. We’re currently going through and changing that in light of this research we’ve done. 🙂

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is 'Submit' bad button text for forms?

The word 'submit' can imply that the pushing of that button acknowledges subservience. All the definitions it showed were essentially about others having more power than you do. Bottom line - who wants to fill in their information and click a button that says 'Submit'?

What are good alternatives to 'Submit' on a lead capture form?

If a lead is filling in a form to get a lead magnet from you, how about using 'Yes, I want this!' as your button text? Or 'Get my copy now' could work as well. Or try 'Yes, send it to me!' if you like that best.

What button text should I use for webinar registration instead of 'Register Now'?

If the form is to register people into a webinar, consider button text along these lines: Save My Spot! Reserve My Seat! Claim My Spot! Doesn't your brain react differently to those options than it does to 'Register Now'?

Why does outcome-focused button text convert better than action-command button text?

The button text labeled as 'boring' is all about the effort. Register, Download, Learn, Click - all are commands that say 'you will do more work when you click this button.' If you focus instead on the outcome - Get My Copy, Save My Seat, etc., they'll be less focused on the effort and more interested in what they'll get.

What can I replace 'Learn More' with on my website buttons?

For your website pages where you want people to click a button to go to another page for more information, what about ditching 'Learn More' and replacing it with 'See the Details,' 'Check It Out,' or perhaps 'Tell Me More'? If you're linking people to a story you've told in a blog post, what about 'Get Inspired by the Story' on your button?

Written by: — Marketing Strategist

Margaret Johnson is a strategic thinker with a knack for getting to the root of challenges and helping to solve them. Devoted to providing education, knowledge, and ideas that help organizations thrive, she works with both entrepreneurs, small, and midsized to drive revenue through effective sales and marketing, lead generation and nurturing programs, content creation, and strategic planning – and, in one example, has used her proven techniques to help an IT services organization grow from four million in revenue to nearly 16 million in revenue. A proponent of “Engagement Marketing,” she believes that the best way to reach potential new customers is through speaking their language, solving their problems, and confronting their issues. An award-winning marketer, Margaret is also an effective and accomplished writer, speaker, presenter, coach, mentor, and collaborator.